Israel, Politics

We’ve Been Waiting 60 Years For Things to Calm Down: Conversation with a Friend From Silwan

I spent ten minutes today speaking with an acquaintance who is Arab and lives in Silwan, a neighborhood of East Jerusalem just south of the Old City. I’ve known him for several years, and we’ve always had a friendly relationship, but I’ve never asked him about his life before. Today I decided to ask how he’s doing. I asked whether he lives in an area where things are really bad, and he told me “everyone lives in an area where it’s really bad.” Then he told me that a couple days ago he drove past the house in Silwan that they demolished this week: “You should have seen what happened – pieces flew everywhere, large chunks of the house, and all of the houses and cars nearby were damaged. It’s never been like that before. I’ve seen houses demolished before, and it was always contained to that house. But this time it was like they didn’t even care what else got damaged. They weren’t even trying to be careful. They didn’t bother cleaning anything up. I don’t know why they did it like that this time.” Thankfully his house is far enough away that it wasn’t affected. (Thankful, really, that I don’t have another person to feel too worried about, at least for today.)

He told me about his 9 year old daughter, his twin 4 year olds, and his 1.5 year old baby. About how the drive to and from their preschool, near Armon Hanatziv, has gotten much longer because of the checkpoints and blockades that have been put into place recently. That it’s taking him much longer to get to and from work because he can no longer drive through Abu Tor. That no one wants to come play in Gan HaPa’amon (in West Jerusalem near the seam line) anymore. That he doesn’t really ever go to the mosque anymore; he used to be religious, but he stopped being religious quite a while ago (he said this a bit apologetically – I told him I understand). He said he thinks things have gotten worse because of social media. It used to be that if something happened, it would take a while for news to spread. Now, everyone knows everything as soon as it happens. It makes people act much more impulsively.
I told him I hope this challenging period will end soon. He said ruefully, “we’ve been waiting for 60 years for things to calm down, to pass. It’s not going to pass. Nothing changes.”
He smiled the whole time we were talking, and wished me a shabbat shalom when we were done.
Yesterday, my five year old asked me, “is an ‘Arab’ a bad person?”
“My friend Shoham told me that Arabs are bad people.”
“Do you know what ‘Arab’ means?”

3 thoughts on “We’ve Been Waiting 60 Years For Things to Calm Down: Conversation with a Friend From Silwan

  1. As usual, Arabs complain about houses being built (for settlers) or destroyed (for terrorists) or vandalized (in “price tag” attacks), Jews complain about being murdered, and “moral” people treat these two complaints with equal seriousness, as if Jewish lives are no more valuable than Arab property.

  2. Grateful you were willing to ask him how he was. Willingness to open up to the Other is a beautiful way to give humanity even to yourself.

  3. Eric, your comment does not seem relevant to this post. The post was not focused in any way on the recent incidents involving Jewish people being brutally murdered. I relate to such horrific events in other posts on this site. The post *is* relating a conversation that took place with a human being whose life has recently gotten more challenging. Are you suggesting that when my friend expressed dismay at a home being destroyed and causing damage to property owned by people unrelated to the original crime, my response should have been “other Arabs did even worse things, so no Arabs have a right to ‘complain'”?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.