Uncategorized

What if millions signed?

One of the most unusual aspects of the conflict in Israel is the relative power American Jewry can have in the making and unmaking of the current circumstances in the Middle East.
The fact that the US is influential in world politics is pretty obvious (and under the current ‘regime’, arguably misguided). Be it economics or culture, choice or coercion – people listen to Uncle Sam.
It is debateable to what degree the Jewish vote is a stimulus to decision making in the power corridors and such speculations often descend into fallacy and hate-mongering. But there is no doubt the lobby carries a profile in the Israeli psyche and the navigation of its governments’ policies. A piquant example is Netanyahu, groomed and feted on American beef for long while, who manages to marry macho native tongue wagging with capitol-hill power-speak. And though no one knows how much money exactly was channelled into the territories since the mid Seventies, it is the kind of money that puts people on the moon. The US government sends a staggering sum of dollars to Israel every year, out of which, Aid money allocated/utilised to/for the settlements is in the ballpark figure of half a billion dollar every year. Private money adds considerable sums.
But this kind of power can work both ways: “Blow and you can extinguish a fire. Blow and you can make a fire.”
So here is an opportunity to do make a difference:

As concerned American Jews united in our unwavering support for Israel, we share your continuing vision of a just and secure resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict – Israel’s best option for long-term stability and security is two democratic states living securely side by side.
What transpires in the months following the Gaza withdrawal will determine the future of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Therefore, we call on you to:

  • Immediately appoint a well-known senior statesman as an envoy to Israel and the Palestinian Authority, to remain on the ground before, during and in the months following the withdrawal.
  • Provide the envoy with a team of monitors to enable independent corroboration of claims by both sides about the steps taken or not taken to implement and coordinate agreements.

The two sides remain far apart in their understanding of their obligations and the necessary coordination of the Israeli withdrawal. The immediate future of international ports of entry, crossings into Israel of goods and people, evacuated settler houses, and much more is still undecided or in dispute.
A prestigious high-level envoy, present in the region on a daily basis, is needed to help both sides reach agreement on the large and small details that must be coordinated to ensure a smooth and successful transition.

More from Brit Tzedek v’Shalom.

4 thoughts on “What if millions signed?

  1. This is a pipe dream everyone knows as soon as Israelis pull out of the west bank and eastern Jerusalem The PLO and HAMAS will hurl enough rockets and morter shells to make your heads spin off perhaps Israel can dismantle some of the far reaching settlements and outposts on the West Bank but its its interesting how quickly you people at brit zedek or should I call you (“Bris” zedek because you want to cut a chunk of Israel off)forget what its looked like when Israel pulled out of Gush Katif well multiply that by a hundred and you have pulling out of large cities like Efrat and Ariel.

  2. Now that Israel is moving on disengagement, any genuine peace and human rights activists must pound the drumbeat for broad recognition of Israel by the Arab-Muslim establishment. Without it, there is no credibility to the peace movement, and no practical incentive for any supporter of Israel anywhere along the political spectrum to sustain the disengagement’s momentum within the peace process.

  3. Provide the envoy with a team of monitors to enable independent corroboration of claims by both sides about the steps taken or not taken to implement and coordinate agreements.
    Why don’t we start ‘corroborating’ about what was done in the past before ignoring it?
    Hello? Thousands of people have been killed in the past 6 years, and we simply say, ‘let’s try something new’ without even bothering to learn from past mistakes? Send in a senior envoy? These people have no clue about what has been going on here. Israel can’t trust ANY American envoy, and frankly, neither can the Arabs.

  4. I think this is a great idea.
    Another idea:
    Historically, Israel received more olim and money from America following victories in battle (as in 1948 and 1967). Some policy-makers came to think that victory in battle would continue to bring Jewish immigrants, and that more territory would be needed to settle the massive influx they incorrectly anticipated. I think American Jews should send the message that they will NOT make aliyah if Israel wims in war, but rather if it wins in peace. There ought to be a petition for American Jews to sign to say that they will make aliyah only following an Israeli withdrawal from the West Bank.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.