Brown & RISD Students Hold Nakba Discussion inside Hillel

On Wednesday, May 11, in the midst of final exams, over 70 Brown University students in the Brown/RISD Hillel community gathered in the Hillel building to watch three short films about the Palestinian Nakba, produced by the Israeli NGO, Zochrot. As members of the Hillel community, we came together to watch these films on the eve of Yom HaAtzmaut, eager to make a space for Jewish students to learn about a history often excluded from mainstream Jewish discourse. In the post-screening discussion, students from diverse political backgrounds reflected on the thought-provoking films and unpacked their relationship to the Nakba as American Jews.

brown risd hillel nakba 2

The Nakba (Arabic for “catastrophe) refers to the expulsion and displacement of approximately 700,000 Palestinians and the demolition of thousands of Palestinian homes in 1948, as well as the ongoing violence committed against Palestinians by the state of Israel. This narrative is not often discussed within the Jewish community. In Israel, a law (referred to as the Nakba law, passed in 2011) authorizes the Finance minister to reduce funding and support for any organization that commemorates the Nakba. In the United States, American Jewish institutions, from AIPAC to Birthright, privilege an exclusionary Zionist narrative of 1948 that ignores the injustices carried out during the creation of the state. By failing to acknowledge this history, these institutions maintain their complicity in the ongoing Nakba, from the displacement of Bedouin communities in the Naqab/Negev to settlement construction in the West Bank. Zochrot (the female form of “remembering” in Hebrew), founded in 2002, promotes acknowledgement and accountability for the Nakba, thus seeking to confront Israeli society with a history that challenges the dominant Jewish narrative of 1948.

Over the past five months, we worked to build a broad-based coalition of Jewish Brown University students interested in pushing the boundaries of the discourse allowed within our Hillel. Institutional frameworks, along with external pressures on Brown RISD Hillel, made the process of planning and executing the “Nakba Film Screening and Discussion” difficult and drawn-out. Throughout this process, the Brown/RISD Hillel staff and student leadership were very supportive of our efforts to achieve greater openness in our community.

However, two days before the screening, one of our co-sponsoring groups, Brown Students for Israel, withdrew support for the event. Without unanimous student group support for the event, our Hillel could no longer endorse the event in an official capacity. Then, after a student leaked information about the event to right-wing pro-Israel publications, security concerns made the gathering at the planned time and place unfeasible. The Hillel building was locked on the day of the event at 7pm due to these concerns.

This event was too important to cancel and we decided to meet informally as a group of students three hours before the planned time of the event to watch and discuss these films. Given the last minute nature of the time-change, we were inspired and thrilled by the large turn-out.

We gathered last night to watch these films and discuss them at Hillel, despite the lack of official Hillel sponsorship. We gathered as Jewish students in the space designated for Jewish life on campus, actively creating the pluralistic community together that we want to see realized in the American Jewish institutions that claim to represent us.

This event was a success not only because it demonstrated the openness of the students in our community, but also because it challenged Brown RISD Hillel to reflect on its ability to facilitate and provide space for this openness. Ultimately, the process of planning this event forced our Hillel to recognize its own lack of openness and to begin reworking its guidelines on Israel/Palestine programming. These guidelines will not be in keeping with the guidelines published and enforced by Hillel International’s in their ‘Standards of Partnership,’ which have been used time and again to silence critical Jewish voices on Israel/Palestine. In order for Hillel to maintain its integrity as a pluralistic Jewish space, the community must embrace Jews who currently feel excluded from mainstream Jewish discourse and who seek to question dominant narratives about Israel.

sophie eital benjamin williams


4 thoughts on “Brown & RISD Students Hold Nakba Discussion inside Hillel

  1. Sounds like a bunch of self serving and self righteous bigots and racists intent on eliminating Israel because they hate Jews. There is nothing “Open” about seeking the destruction of Israel. There is nothing liberal nor progressive about supporting groups which discriminate violently against Jews, execute gays, support terror, oppress women, persecute religious minorities, exporting terror and making the region judenrein.

  2. These “Nakaba truth tellers” always spin and twist the facts to fit the BDS leftist narrative. At the same time they kept mum about the real and violent expulsion of 850 thousand Jews by Arabs in 1948. The whole game is to demonize Israeli Jews and call for Muslim Arab dominance over the Jewish state. If Arabs take over, then they will massacre and expell the Jews. Enough said.

  3. Zochrot advocates the return of 5 Million Arabs to Israel. How is that conducive to peace ? It would mean civil war and the destruction on Israel.

  4. Congratulations to Sophie Kasakove, Eital Schattner-Elmaleh, and Ben Williams for the difficult but important working to make a truly inclusive Jewish community at Brown/RISD Hillel. Efforts by the Jewish community to tell only one side of the story about what happened 1947-49 doesn’t serve Israel nor does it serve inquisitive young Jews on campus.
    Also impressive was how Brown Students for Israel was part of the organizing committee. Very impressive. It’s sad, but not surprising that outside pressures led the Brown Students for Israel to withdraw. That shouldn’t diminish the important fact that a broad consensus of Jewish students, in opposition to International Hillel guidelines and with the support of Brown/RISD Hillel staff were interested in learning about the Nakba and creating an open forum for discussion.
    Keep up the good work.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.